Next month, HBO’s new sensation, “The Idol,” a drama delving into the music industry, stardom, and explicit adult content, is set to air.
Created by the renowned Abel Tesfaye, popularly known as The Weeknd, and Sam Levinson, the force behind another HBO hit, “Euphoria,” “The Idol” is making waves even before its public premiere. The plot revolves around Jocelyn, a rising pop star portrayed by Lily-Rose Depp, who falls for a cult leader and nightclub owner, played by Tesfaye. This torrid romance has provoked various reactions, with some critics categorizing it as exploitative and explicit. (HBO and CNN both fall under the umbrella of Warner Bros. Discovery.)
Despite only being previewed to critics at the Cannes Film Festival, “The Idol” has been controversial for months. According to Rolling Stone, the initial director quit when the show was near completion, sparking reports of a tumultuous production environment. The show currently sits with a disappointing 27% approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes.
Outside of the Cannes preview, no other review copies of the show have been released by HBO.
As we inch towards its June 4 premiere, here’s a synopsis of the tumult surrounding “The Idol.”
Report Unveils Unsettled Production and Controversial Plotlines
Earlier this year, Rolling Stone reported on “The Idol,” citing 13 anonymous sources claiming that the show had spiralled out of control.
In April 2022, director Amy Seimetz departed the project despite nearly completing the six-episode series. The plan was to launch the show by the end of 2022. However, following her departure, Levinson assumed control of the project and chose to rewrite and reshoot, causing a delay.
According to Rolling Stone, Levinson altered the central narrative of the show. While Seimetz had emphasized Depp’s character and the warped repercussions of fame, Levinson shifted the focus towards a bad romance.
Those involved with production described a chaotic environment, with half-finished scripts and repeatedly shot scenes. HBO assured Rolling Stone that their creative team was dedicated to fostering a safe, collaborative, and respectful work environment, and the alterations were made in the best interest of all involved.
Following the Rolling Stone article, Tesfaye posted a show clip on Twitter where Depp’s character rejects a Rolling Stone cover, quipping, “(Rolling Stone) did we upset you?”
The Cast Defends ‘The Idol’ Amidst Negative Critiques and Allegations
After its Cannes premiere, “The Idol” has faced predominantly negative reviews. The Hollywood Reporter criticized Levinson’s inconsistent direction and the narrative’s focus on explicit content. Variety labelled the show as a “sordid male fantasy,” while other critics have termed it “gross and sexist.”
However, the cast remains supportive of Levinson and “The Idol.” Depp defended the show, stating her experience did not reflect the adverse reports. Tesfaye also stood by the show, noting that the aim was to create a dark, twisted fairy tale based on the music industry. Hank Azaria and Jane Adams lauded Levinson and condemned the scrutinizing society, advocating for the freedom to create.
Levinson remained seemingly unfazed at the Cannes press conference, predicting “The Idol” would be the summer’s biggest show.
Sam Levinson’s History of Controversy
Best known for the Emmy-winning show “Euphoria,” Levinson has faced criticism for the show’s explicit portrayal of teenage life, which some viewers have deemed excessive. Nonetheless, many cast members have stated they feel comfortable with the level of nudity on the show, citing the presence of intimacy coordinators on set to ensure safety and comfort. However, a few have admitted to pushing back when they deem nudity unnecessary.
Despite the negative press and controversy surrounding “The Idol,” the excitement and anticipation for its premiere are undeniable. With a high-profile cast and creators with a history of generating hits, the show has already captured the public’s attention. As viewers and critics prepare for its debut, they wonder whether the series will live up to its hype or succumb to its controversies. Regardless, one thing’s sure: everyone will be watching when “The Idol” premieres on HBO and Max on June 4.
